2024 Rookie ILBs: Who will make an impact?

Mid-round selections, looking to provide high-ceiling performances.

A composite of the ideal NFL middle linebacker of yesteryear might include the laser-focused eyes of Mike Singletary, the intensity of Ray Lewis and Dick Butkus, and the non-stop sideline-to-sideline hustle of Luke Kuechly.

These greats also demonstrated an impeccable knowledge of the game and their position, as well as the leadership skills needed to be the “quarterback of the defense.”

But they also played, for the most part, in a 4-3 defense, in which they alone manned the middle. In today's NFL, the middle linebacker has become increasingly rare. Instead, he shares his snaps with a fellow inside ‘backer in a 3-4 schemes.

Yet even their play as a pair is diminishing. Inside linebackers are the first players displaced when defenses increase defensive backs from four to five (nickel), to six (dime with no ILBs), and even seven (the penny).

Here is a clue: In 2023, NFL defenses used the nickel more than 67 percent of the time and went all the way to the penny more than 19 percent of the time.

But in the past few drafts, teams tried to fortify the disappearing position of ILB anyway. In 2023, the Lions paired first-round selection Jack Campbell with holdover Alex Anzalone to form an inside tandem that anchored an improved Detroit defense.

In this year’s draft, Green Bay doubled up on the position, taking ILBs Edgerrin Cooper (Texas A&M) in the second round and Ty’Ron Hopper (Round 3, Missouri) to compete for playing time next to 2022 first-round selection Quay Walker.

Ultimately, 19 inside linebackers were chosen in this year's draft, the majority going in Rounds 3–5. (The first interior ‘backer did not go until the second round.) A few of these newbies might make an immediate impact; most will not. Let’s rank these new NFL linebackers as to how we expect them to perform in their rookie seasons:

19. Tatum Bethune, Florida State: 6-1, 225

Draft: 7th round, 251st overall, San Francisco 49ers

College highlights

Throughout his career, Bethune was a formidable presence, accumulating an impressive total of 339 tackles. His 28 tackles for loss and 7.5 sacks demonstrates his ability to disrupt plays in the opponent’s backfield.

Impact outlook

Even if he were not the last inside linebacker drafted, Bethune faces an uphill climb on the depth chart. Sitting ahead of him are All-Pro talents Fred Warner and Dre Greenlaw, and whether Bethune gets any meaningful snaps as a rookie likely hinges on Greenlaw's recovery from an Achilles tear in the Super Bowl. But with Greenlaw potentially becoming an unrestricted free agent next offseason on a financially challenged 49ers team, Bethune might get a shot to contribute in 2025 — provided he shows enough development on the practice field in 2024.

18. Jamal Hill, Oregon: 6-0, 200

Draft: 6th round, 188th overall, Houston Texans

College highlights

Hill was a steady presence on Oregons’ defense, accumulating 148 tackles over his career. In coverage, he broke up 13 passes, showing a proficiency for making plays on the ball in pass coverage. His versatility was an asset for the Ducks, and Houston hopes that asset carries over to the NFL.

Impact outlook

Hill, originally a safety, brings exceptional speed to the linebacker position, which head coach Demeco Ryans plans to leverage. Look for the Texans to create a scheme to deploy Hill as a defensive spy against mobile quarterbacks, a crucial strategy against division rival Anthony Richardson, whose athleticism will pose a significant challenge.

17. Jaylan Ford, Texas: 6-2, 221

Draft: 5th round, 175th overall, New Orleans Saints

College highlights

A standout performer for the Longhorns, Ford amassed an impressive 287 career tackles. His penchant for wreaking havoc in offensive backfields made itself clear with 27.5 tackles for loss. In coverage, his six interceptions underscored his knack for diagnosing passing plays and creating turnovers.

Impact outlook

Known for his raw athleticism and potential, Ford likely faces a learning curve in adapting to the speed of the professional game. He does, though, have the chance to learn under veterans Demario Davis and Pete Werner, which could give him an inside track on competing for a starting role in 2025.

16. Michael Barrett, Michigan: 6-0, 227

Draft: 7th round, 240th overall, Carolina Panthers

College highlights

Barrett racked up 208 career tackles, with 12 being for loss. He ended his career with 8.5 sacks, demonstrating that he is capable of pressuring quarterbacks. Spending six years at the University of Michigan, he concluded his Wolverine career as a team captain and holds the record for most games played (64). His contributions were instrumental to the success of last year's national championship-winning team, reinforcing a value beyond draft metrics.

Impact outlook

Barrett was the second inside linebacker selected by the Carolina Panthers. As an undersized linebacker with unflattering speed (4.70), Barrett hopes his leadership skills and championship pedigree will offset any metrics-based deficiencies. Carolina, despite winning just two games last year, boasts a strong defense, so it is unlikely Barrett gets off the sideline in 2024.

15. Ty’Ron Hopper, Missouri: 6-2, 228

Draft: 3rd round, 91st overall, Green Bay Packers

College highlights

Hopper's statistics may not jump out at you, but his impact as a defender emerged after he transferred from Florida, where he was underutilized, to Missouri. Over the past two seasons with the Tigers, Hopper totaled 214 tackles, including an eye-popping 31 tackles for loss. His 9.5 career sacks is a testament to his ability to get after the QB from the linebacker position.

Impact outlook

This former Florida Gator who transitioned to Mizzou concluded his college journey as a Butkus Award finalist, and his impressive physical attributes revealed his potential at the NFL level. However, he does not seem to possess the instinctive play typically observed in a top-tier inside linebacker. He faces competition from fellow rookie Edgerrin Cooper, also drafted by the Pack, one round ahead Hopper. As July camps approach, Cooper appears to be favored for the starting role alongside Quay Walker.

14. Edefuan Ulofoshio, Washington: 6-1, 235

Draft: 5th round, 160th overall, Buffalo Bills

College highlights

A former walk-on with the Washington Huskies, Ulofoshio persevered through early-career injuries to emerge as a finalist for the Butkus Award in his final season, and contributed to a national championship runner-up team. It was his only full season, but Ulofoshio made the most of it, logging 94 total tackles, including eight for loss, and helping lead his team to the National Championship game. He also had a pick-six on the season.

Impact outlook

The resilience and mental toughness Ulofoshio showed in overcoming adversity caught the attention of the Bills. He faces stiff competition at inside linebacker, where standout Matt Milano, one of the team’s top defenders, will man one inside spot. However, Milano is still recovering from a broken leg that ended his 2023 season. If he’s slow to regain his form, Ulofoshio might get a chance to contribute in 2024.

13. Jordan Magee, Temple: 6-3, 210

Draft: 5th round, 139th overall, Washington Commanders

College highlights

Magee steadily improved over the course of his college career with the Owls. He earned a starting role in 2021 and recorded 54 total tackles, bumping up that number to 86 the next season. In 2023, Magee racked up 14 tackles for loss.

Impact outlook

Magee stands out in the 2024 ILB class thanks to his exceptional athletic ability. But he needs to refine his game and display more patience, as he too often attacks the line of scrimmage prematurely. Magee does finds himself in an ideal learning environment in Washington, where he will be mentored by veteran ILB Bobby Wagner, who played under new Commanders’ head coach Dan Quinn in Seattle.

12. JD Bertrand, Notre Dame: 6-1, 228

Draft: 5th round, 143rd overall, Atlanta Falcons

College highlights

Bertrand's collegiate career includes a standout 2021 season, when he recorded 101 total tackles, including seven for loss and 1.5 sacks, in 13 games. His overall tackle numbers did dip in 2022 (86 total tackles) and 2023 (76), though he still made a number of plays in the backfields of opposing offenses.

Impact outlook

Falcons fans have reason to be optimistic about Bertrand's potential. A currently shaky situation at inside linebacker for the Falcons means there could be an opportunity for Bertrand to secure playing time alongside Kaden Ellis. Bertrand could have a rookie season reminiscent of Malcolm Rodriguez, who, as a rookie, became a fan favorite in Detroit before Jack Campbell's arrival.

11. Tommy Eichenberg, Ohio St: 6-2, 235

Draft: 5th round, 148th overall, Las Vegas Raiders

College highlights:

Eichenberg established himself as a full-time starter for the Buckeyes in the 2021 season, appearing in 13 games and tallying 64 total tackles, including 6.5 tackles for loss. His play saw a significant leap the following year, as he nearly doubled those numbers. Eichenberg's breakout year—despite playing 10 games—highlighted a dynamic presence on the field and showcased his ability to make plays behind the line of scrimmage.

Impact Outlook

To Raider fans old enough to remember both, Eichenberg is an amalgam of Bill Romanowski and Matt Millen, themselves fiery linebackers who donned the silver and black. Expect head coach Antonio Pierce, himself a former NFL linebacker, to embrace Eichenberg’s competitive spirit.

10. Nathaniel Watson, Mississippi St: 6-2, 245

Draft: 6th round, 206th overall, Cleveland Browns

College highlights

Last year’s SEC Defensive Player of the Year, Watson posted a terrifically productive 2023, notching 137 total tackles, 13 tackles for loss, and 10 sacks. Despite these impressive numbers, Watson waited until Day 3 to hear his name called. His slide in the draft was in no way indicative of his play for the Bulldogs last year.

Impact outlook

Watson has the potential to make an immediate impact. His college coaches praised his defensive IQ and were impressed by his ability to play multiple positions. Cleveland's ILB situation currently features an aging Jordan Hicks and Devin Bush, who is already on his third team in as many years. Watson could have ample opportunities to see playing time.

9. Darius Muasau, UCLA: 6-1, 230

Draft: 6th round, 183rd overall, New York Giants

College highlights

Muasau began his college career at Hawaii, where he wreaked havoc on opposing offenses for three seasons. This included a 100-tackle season in 2020, despite only playing nine games. After transferring, he adjusted to stiffer competition by becoming the team leader in tackles in both seasons for the Bruins, earning consecutive Second-Team Pac 12 Conference honors along the way.

Impact outlook

Muasau has the potential to quickly become a valuable asset to the Giants’ defense. Known for his relentless pursuit—though he’s prone to overrunning plays—and strong pass coverage skills, Muasau, even as a rookie, might make the immediate impact his team needs at the position.

8. Jeremiah Trotter Jr., Clemson: 6-1, 210

Draft: 5th round, 155th overall, Philadelphia Eagles

College highlights

As a freshman, Trotter produced little for Clemson, despite appearing in all 13 games. However, he displayed remarkable consistency over the next two seasons, averaging 90 tackles per season, to go along with double-digit tackles for losses. He also intercepted four passes, returning two of them for touchdowns. These performances led to Second-Team Associated Press All-American honors in consecutive seasons.

Impact outlook

Trotter Jr. begins his NFL journey with the same team as his father. His football intelligence, exceptional body control, and relentless effort compensate for any physical limitations one might link to a 210-pound frame. The Eagles’ defense struggled mightily down the stretch of 2023, so any infusion of energy and talent—homegrown or otherwise—is welcome.

7. Tyrice Knight, UTEP: 6-2, 240lb

Draft: 4th round, 118th overall, Seattle Seahawks

College highlights

Knight faced a slow start in his first year after transferring from a JC, but he put forth consistent production during his two seasons at UTEP. His final season was especially noteworthy as he racked up 140 total tackles, including 15.5 for loss, and added 4.5 sacks.

Impact outlook

New head coach Mike Macdonald had the luxury as Baltimore’s DC of having a plethora of talented bodies at the ILB position. However, the Seahawks urgently require stability and leadership at the inside linebacker position, making Knight's role crucial in addressing their needs and restoring consistency to the defense. He undoubtedly has the natural ability to crack the starting lineup, but his so-so skills at diagnosing plays and to play within a scheme may be what prevents him from doing so.

6. Marist Liufau, Notre Dame: 6-2, 226

Draft: 3rd round, 87th overall, Dallas Cowboys

College highlights

Liufau's college statistics may appear underwhelming: 118 tackles, 12 tackles for loss, and four sacks—numbers often exceeded in a single college season by some players. Nevertheless, he distinguished himself as a 2023 Butkus Award semifinalist.

Impact outlook

The underwhelming college stats did not discourage the Cowboys’ from valuing what Liufau shows on film — and that is remarkable athleticism, which he effectively uses to excel in both run defense and pass coverage. The Cowboys need immediate contributions at the inside ‘backer position, so it is possible Liufau gets a chance to contribute right from the start.

5. Cedric Gray, North Carolina: 6-2, 225

Draft: 4th round, 106th overall, Tennessee Titans

College highlights

In his Tar Heel career, Gray compiled notable defensive statistics across the board: 369 total tackles, 30 tackles for loss, and 8.5 sacks. He also exhibited a knack for creating turnovers with five interceptions and five fumble recoveries. He finished his collegiate career with consecutive All-ACC Team honors.

Impact outlook

Gray joins a Titans team with a new coaching staff and an intent on improving the defensive side of the ball. Gray factors into those plans, joining veterans L’Jarius Sneed and Kenneth Murray, and fellow 2024 draftee, T’Vondre Sweat. A veteran linebacker presence is in place to mentor Gray, as he needs to improve his technique to make an impact at the NFL level.

4. Payton Wilson, North Carolina St: 6-4, 235

Draft: 3rd round, 98th overall, Pittsburgh Steelers

College highlights

Payton Wilson's college career was marked by numerous twists and turns as he recovered from major shoulder injuries to become the 2023 winner of both the Chuck Bednarik Defensive Player of the Year and Butkus Awards. These accolades underscore his special production on the field in 2023—138 tackles, 17.5 tackles for loss, and six sacks. His coverage skills were also obvious: three INTs and six pass break-ups last year.

Impact outlook

The blue-collar work ethic Wilson exemplified throughout his collegiate career will fit well in the Steel City. He joins a linebacker room that features two dominant NFL defenders: TJ Watt, when healthy a perennial contender for Defensive Player of the Year; and Patrick Queen, a new arrival from the hated Ravens who could accelerate Wilson’s transition to the NFL. This trio could form a formidable unit, one poised to revive Pittsburgh's equally formidable defensive legacy.

3. Trevin Wallace, Kentucky: 6-2, 220 (188cm, 99kg)

Draft: 3rd round, 72nd overall, Carolina Panthers

College highlights

Wallace progressed from All-SEC Freshman team honors to team captain in 2023, and he produced the stats in his final season to warrant the promotion: 80 tackles, including 8.5 tackles for loss and 5.5 sacks.

Impact outlook

Wallace will be tasked with restoring pride to a position with a storied history: Sam Mills (1995–1997), Dan Morgan (2001–2007), Thomas Davis (2005–2013), and 2013 NFL Defensive Player of the Year, Luke Kuechly. The new Panthers’ ILB makes up for his limited college experience and underwhelming size with speed and explosiveness.

2. Edgerrin Cooper, Texas A&M: 6-2, 220lb (188cm, 99kg)

Draft: 2nd round, 45th overall, Green Bay Packers

College highlights

Despite teams actively trying to avoid him in his final season with the Aggies, Cooper managed to rack up 84 tackles, including 17 for loss. And he sacked opposing QBs eight times. He earned first team All-SEC and Associated Press All-American recognition.

Impact outlook

Cooper’s transition to the NFL and his role in the Packers' defense will be closely monitored, particularly as he competes against quarterbacks Caleb Williams and J.J. McCarthy, fellow rookies within the NFC North. Cooper excels at evading blocks and making dynamic plays, whether in pursuit or when blitzing. These qualities, combined with his partnership with Quay Walker, lead me to project him as a strong candidate for Defensive Rookie of the Year (DROY).

1. Junior Colson, Michigan: 6-2, 225lb 

Draft: 3rd round, 69th overall, Los Angeles Chargers

College highlights

Colson's path to collegiate success is marked by resilience and determination, beginning with his early life in Haiti and his adoption by the Colson family in 2012. His transition to football at the University of Michigan showcased his natural talent and unwavering dedication to the game.

Immediately from his freshman year forward, Colson became a cornerstone of Michigan's defense. By his sophomore season, he demonstrated significant growth, amassing over 100 tackles, six tackles for loss, and two sacks. These contributions were instrumental in Michigan's journey to winning the 2023 National Championship, with Colson leading the team with 95 tackles across 15 games.

His outstanding performance on the field was recognized with the prestigious Lott IMPACT Award, highlighting his embodiment of integrity, maturity, academic excellence, community involvement, and tenacity—traits synonymous with the award's namesake, Ronnie Lott.

Impact outlook

Colson's move to the NFL places him back under the mentorship of Jim Harbaugh, this time with the Chargers. This familiarity could facilitate a smoother transition for Colson as he adapts to the fast-paced environment of professional football. With minimal competition on the current Chargers roster at the ILB position, and Colson's history of perseverance and notable collegiate achievements, he is poised to make substantial noise in the NFL as a rookie.